Ground trampolines and Phase Locked Loops

A customer was using the UPduino v2.1 low-cost Lattice iCE40 FPGA board in their prototype to check out some IP in the FPGA. This IP required the use of a Phase Locked Loop (PLL) within the FPGA to generate specific frequencies that the design required.

The customer reported that the FPGA PLL was going out of lock intermittently.

Background

Phase locked loops are useful blocks (and there is one in the Lattice iCE40 UP5K FPGA) used to generate specific clock frequencies that may not necessarily be an integer multiple of a reference clock. The principle of operation is covered very well in this Wikipedia article.

The UPduino 2.1 is a low cost FPGA board thats designed for fast prototyping. The board has a couple of voltage regulators, an FT232H USB to SPI bridge, flash for FPGA code storage and supporting passives. The board is laid out on 2 layers.

Debug

Test Case

I was able to duplicate the failure mode on my setup which consisted of an UPduino connected to the customers test board. By a process of elimination, I was able to get the PLL to fail with an FPGA design consisting of the PLL, an output clock from the PLL, a GPIO input and an LED output from the FPGA. This rather minimal design exhibited the symptoms described by the user in a significantly more complex design.

On to Debug

Now that I had the test case, it was time to delve deeper: why would such a simple design cause the PLL to lose lock and that too by toggling a switch to the FPGA! This strange behavior was also not consistent: pushing the switch would intermittently cause the PLL to go out of lock. There didn't appear to be any pattern to the behavior either.

I was also able to eliminate the customer board as the source of the issue. I checked all DC power supplies on the UPduino and customer board with a multi-meter, things looked good. Searching online gave me a hint on what to pursue next, (isn't information sharing a wonderful thing!) ie. clock quality and board layout.

From my experience, I knew that PLL's were finicky analog creatures and had to be cared for by low jitter input clocks and proper filtering of the power supply.

A simple change I made was to source a clean 12MHz clock from an external crystal instead of using the on-board resonator which has poor phase noise in comparison. This seemed to reduce the probability of PLL unlocking but didnt make the issue go away.

Power and Ground

The dedicated power supply on the PLL and the ground near it looked good with about 10-15mV of digital noise, not too bad. Its important to follow proper probing guidelines when making such measurements!

I probed the DC voltages and noticed a substantial noise of >50mV or so on the supplies. This was significantly reduced by adding 10uF caps on the LDO's. However, this didnt seem to improve the probability of the PLL losing lock.

I then measured the ground plane from one end of the board to the other. I was shocked to see huge spikes on the ground plane! This meant that the various circuits on the board had a different view of what they considered a reference.

The UPduino is a small board, about 2.2cm x 5.1cm. Having the ground plane be different by hundreds of mV across such a small board, that too with such a simple design on the FPGA, not consuming much power seemed to indicate something was very wrong!

I analyzed the board layout in Eagle and noticed that the Ground plane was routed on the bottom side as follows:

The solid filled areas are the ground plane in the above picture. As you can see, the ground plane is split into multiple discrete sections, never a good idea! This gave me a good idea of what to try next. I used copper braid to short across various sections of the ground plane and was able to get the noise down significantly. More importantly, this correlated well with a decreasing probability of the PLL failing to lock. A good indication that I was on the right track.

Unfortunately, all the hacking was not able to restore a reliable PLL lock on this board. Needless to say, the customer was unable to use this board for their design as the board design was to blame.

Next Steps and a New Beginning!

I had inherited the design from the original manufacturer/designer. This experience, as well as the feedback from users about various features missing from the UPduino, got me thinking about coming up with the next generation of the board.

UPduino 3.0!

I kicked off the next generation: the UPduino 3.0, with a goal of not just fixing the layout but adding significant features as documented on this GitHub site.

The ground plane on the UPduino 3.0 is a solid plane with no cuts. This was a hard requirement on the layout. The power plane does have some cuts but shouldn't be too significant as shown in the plots below. A detailed review was done to ensure that power and grounds had sufficiently thick traces and decoupling caps were placed close to the pins being decoupled. A 0.1uF/4.7uF capacitor combination was settled on as a standard decoupling strategy. Going to a 4 layer board made the design implementable: it was clear during routing of this board that the original design with 2 layers was simply not feasible and a bad design choice in the first place. The extra cost of going to 4 layers vs. 2 layers was simply not worth the risk.

UPduino 3.0 ground plane

UPduino 3.0 power plane

The first version of the design is now complete and will be fabricated soon with a high expectation that the PLL will lock!

If you would like to be involved, please feel free to browse Discourse and/or join the Discord channel!

204 comments

  • FB friends spy is a facebook windows application that offers to its user’s information about their friends they cannot find in there profiles:
    1. Online presence information (offline/online) even if you are in offline chat mode.
    2. People most interested by them.
    3. People most interacting with them(on comments not messages , spying on messages is illegal and forbidden by facebook, so it is impossible to do, thank you for your understanding).
    4. latest Facebook statuses
    5. Places visited.
    6. Events attending or already participated in
    FB friend’s spy will ask you for permissions to offer you the information you want, this information will and still be used only by you, it will not be used by anyone else.
    FB friend’s spy uses Facebook SDK to connect to Facebook, so users don’t have to worry about their private or secret information.

    project wheels the gamecrazy taxi playstation 3cyberlink webcam splitter 6.0grey spirit dark souls 2nvidia gt 520 driverblack friday galaxy s5galaxy s6 active marshmallow attasphalt xtreme apk downloadstar wars force unleashed 2 trainerdeak starkiller force unleashed 2
    do toshiba laptops have bluetooth

    mustak 1200 ub plus

    scx-4623fw driver

    fifa 16 ps4 update

    harley davidson race to the rally

    wireless mouse for windows 8

    sims freeplay wedding cake

    corsair padlock 2 hack

    asus p8b75 m le

    super mario rpg legend of the five pendants

    gigabyte ga-b75m-hd3
    sony dcr-trv340 driver windows 10
    gta online car missing from garage
    champions online xbox 360
    sound blaster e5 software

    https://bit.ly/3fAq5Ui
    https://bit.ly/2RTa2rU
    https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-selfish-net-for-windows-10-selfishnet/
    https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-photoshop-cs3-windows-10-64-bit-adobe/
    https://bit.ly/2R9p78j
    https://rd-ok.ru/download-winpcap-for-windows-10-winpcap-has-ceased/
    https://hanralecon1988.wordpress.com/2021/05/21/hay-day-game-for-pc-windows-10-free-download-hay/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/simmons-sd500-5-piece-electronic-drum-set-simmons/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/p8p67-deluxe-windows-10-asus-p8p67-ahci-drivers/
    https://bit.ly/2RWoS0Q

    atom text editor portable
    lumia 950 pre order
    edimax drivers windows 10
    diablo 3 hacked items
    game with gold september 2015

    what is scm msi
    crusader kings 2 charlemagne events
    asus p8h61 m lx2 drivers
    starcraft 2 collectors edition
    microsoft basic optical mouse v2.0

    edimax drivers windows 7
    ga-a55m-ds2
    jvc kw-r910bt update
    game of thrones mini throne
    axis p3225-lve

    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-file-sync-download-windows-10-freefilesync/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-download-anyconnect-for-windows-10-anyconnect/
    https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-tcpdump-for-windows-10-tcpdump-for/
    https://bit.ly/34yuzVf
    http://seominds.ru/tag/секрет успеха/
    http://newintheworld1234.blogspot.com/2021/05/gmail-download-for-pc-windows-10results.html
    https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-realtek-ethernet-controller-driver/
    https://rd-ok.ru/download-windows-10-for-free-on-pc-download/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/rat-3-gaming-mouse-code-52-for-usb-mouse-mad-catz/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-download-icons-for-windows-10-pichon-free/

    hp probook 440 drivers

    samsung activity tracker apk

    lenovo ideapad z565 drivers

    dell v715w printer driver

    dragon age origins revenant

    wifi calling axon 7

    atv usb creator windows

    creative xfi windows 10

    creative sound blaster live 24-bit external

    nvidia quadro fx 1800m driver

    RobertRib
  • download facebook spy tool

    download game mortal kombat pc ringanelgato video capture software download windows free freebird hunter pc game free downloadhitman absolution download windows 10hp officejet pro 8500a plus driver download windows 10501 free new escape games download for pctwitter download for windows 8 freefree download malwarebytes for windows 10 64 bitfirefox for windows xp free download freedownload game fast and furious tokyo drift pc
    windows error sound download free

    download windows 10 pro iso 64 bit full version espanol

    download windows 8.1 torrents free

    adb driver for windows 10 free download

    free download of latest vlc player for windows xp free

    dr web antivirus free download windows 10

    firewatch pc game download

    microsoft windows xp trial download free

    air force pc games free download

    iball download windows 10

    canon lbp2900b software free download for windows xp free
    download windows 10 x64 bit
    civilisation pc game download
    free download of microsoft software for windows xp free
    windows live movie maker effects download free free

    https://fundamentservis.ru/folio-builder-indesign-cc-tutorial-2-managing-a/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/en-windows-10-business-editions-version-1903-x64/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/this-video-is-no-longer-available-due-to-a/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/onenote-gem-add-ins-anchor-to-onenote/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-webcam-software-windows-10-download-14-best/

    cake mania pc game free download
    download game world of tanks offline pc
    download minecraft pe free for pc windows 10
    download game ps4 emulator for pc
    allshare download for pc windows 8

    chinese keyboard download windows 7 free
    bully game free download for pc
    ibm thinkpad t42 audio drivers for windows xp free download free
    download pubg lite for pc windows 10
    halo 2 pc download windows 7

    airfoil download windows free
    duke nukem manhattan project pc game download
    download netflix for pc windows 7
    windows gadgets 7 free download free
    atksgt sys windows 10 download

    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-download-torrentbit-software-for-windows-10/
    https://rd-ok.ru/download-windows-10-ultimate-64-bit-windows-10/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/liveware-extension-for-smartwatch-messaging-smart/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-steam-download-for-windows-10-steam-for/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/acronis-ati-hd-2013-true-image-2013-by-acronis/

    free download twitter for laptop windows 10

    microsoft office 2010 full version free download for windows 8 free

    essae pr 85 thermal printer driver download windows 10

    dragon ball z raging blast 2 free download for pc

    collage maker app for pc free download

    free download spss 16 software for windows 7 free

    free download dropbox for windows 10

    hotspot for pc windows 7 download

    29 card game free download for pc windows 8

    bookworm adventures 2 free download full version for windows 10

    Annasysvem
  • download facebook spy tool

    windows xp cd rom driver download free freewindows 7 wont download anything freevideo codec windows xp download freedownload adobe pdf reader for pc windows 10free download machinarium game full version for pcdownload backup windows 10intel i3 2100 graphics driver download windows 10chrome offline download for windows 10 64 bitdownload windows xp home edition backup software freelinksys ae3000 driver windows 10 download
    java 84 bit download windows 10

    big bash game download for pc

    ubuntu download for windows 7 64 bit free

    directplay windows 8.1 free download free

    download minecraft bedrock windows 10

    adobe flash player 10.1 download windows xp

    english uk language pack windows 10 download

    ie 12 download for windows 10

    cooking dash free download full version for pc

    chinese language pack windows 10 download

    artificial academy 2 free download windows 10 free
    dock for windows 10 free download
    free pc apps download windows 10
    acrobat pdf reader for windows 10 free download
    prototype free download for pc windows 10

    https://chromebrowser.ru/easy-capture-manager-download-windows-10-samsung/
    https://mixpresent.ru/wacomtablet-6-3-15-2-subscribe-to-rss/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/find-windows-10-download-download-windows-10/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-download-language-pack-for-windows-10/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/nes-red-light-flashing-how-to-troubleshoot/

    fortnite for windows 10 download
    windows 2012 r2 download iso free
    download elo touchscreen driver windows 10
    horror games download for pc windows 10
    download jvm windows 7 free

    windows small business server 2008 download free
    download heywire for windows 7 free
    clipgrab download for windows 10
    cardfight vanguard online game download for pc
    ms word download for pc windows 10 free

    spmc download for windows free
    modio download windows 10 free
    cd dvd burning software free download for windows 10
    hp wireless button driver windows 7 download free
    microsoft antivirus windows 7 64 bit free download free

    https://fundamentservis.ru/world-of-warcraft-blood-elf-model-artcraft-blood/
    https://mixpresent.ru/asrock-z170-pro4s-bios-update-asrock-z170-pro4s/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/amd-install-manager-download-windows-10-amd/
    https://rd-ok.ru/alexa-for-windows-10-download-amazon-alexa/
    http://hkszfwdh.blogspot.com/2021/05/google-chrome-won-t-download-on-windows.html

    desktop calendar download windows 10

    croc legend of the gobbos pc download free

    download microsoft excel for windows 7 pc

    roblox download free pc windows 7

    siri for pc windows 7 free download

    directx 11 download windows 10 64 bit offline installer

    hyper v manager free download for windows 10

    call of duty demo free download for pc

    catia software free download for windows 10

    audio video player software free download for pc

    Annasysvem
  • acceptance auto insurance
    car insurance ontario
    car insurance companies
    vehicle insurance
    get auto insurance online

    Cyril
  • microsoft office 2010 download gratis portugues completo para windows 7 freegoogle talk video call download for windows 7 freehow to download windows 7 with a product key freedigjim game download for pcdownload diablo 2 full game free pcwindows 98 maze screensaver download freedownload discord pc windows 10outlook express windows xp download freemame32 games free download full version for pc windows xp freedownload cursorfx for windows 10
    [url=https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-portable-device-driver-for-windows-10/]broforce free download pc
    [/url]
    [url=https://bestsmiles.net.ru/adobe-reader-for-windows-10-64-bit-free-download-4/]antivirus for windows 10 free download full version
    [/url]
    [url=https://rd-ok.ru/download-windows-10-64-pro-iso-how-to-download/]free download windows 10 loader
    [/url]
    [url=https://bestsmiles.net.ru/adobe-reader-touch-free-download-for-windows-10/]car racing game download for pc windows 7
    [/url]
    [url=https://chromebrowser.ru/free-download-of-adobe-reader-for-windows-10/]ammyy admin download for windows 10
    [/url]
    [url=https://fundamentservis.ru/officejet-pro-6970-driver-hp-customer-support/]download cisco webex for windows 10 free
    [/url]
    [url=https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-pes-2018-for-windows-10-pro-evolution/]hp wireless button driver windows 7 download free
    [/url]
    [url=https://fundamentservis.ru/ati-radeon-hd-2400-driver-available-22-files-for/]taskbar for windows xp free download free
    [/url]
    [url=https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-teredo-tunneling-pseudo-interface-windows/]download gom player for pc windows 10
    [/url]
    [url=https://rd-ok.ru/download-windows-10-loader-free-download-windows/]download andy for windows 10 64 bit
    [/url]
    google play store app download for pc windows 7
    freddi fish pc game download
    free download windows defender for windows 7 32 bit free
    drum games free download pc
    uc browser for windows 10 pc free download

    https://rd-ok.ru/64-bit-jdk-download-windows-10-java-development/
    https://rd-ok.ru/droid4x-latest-version-download-for-windows-10/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/command-and-conquer-3-patch-tiberium-wars-patch-1/
    https://rd-ok.ru/download-windows-10-disk-iso-file-download-windows/
    https://bestsmiles.net.ru/download-pages-for-windows-10-pages-for-pc-and-mac/

    chromecast download pc windows 7
    safari browser for windows 7 32 bit free download free
    download desktop clock windows 10
    download windows 10 wifi driver 64 bit
    mp3 cutter and joiner free download for windows 7 32bit free

    free download apache openoffice for windows 8 free
    free windows 7 ultimate upgrade download free
    spss for windows 10 download free
    microsoft windows xp home edition free download free
    game pc all free download

    download free nba live 2008 pc game full version
    battlefield v pc game free download
    download free counter strike global offensive pc game full version
    alien shooter 2 pc game free download
    download winamp for windows 10 64 bit

    https://rd-ok.ru/alfa-network-awus036h-driver-windows-10-download/
    https://fundamentservis.ru/editing-meshes-in-nifskope-how-to-create-static/
    https://chromebrowser.ru/free-download-bluetooth-driver-for-windows-10-32/
    https://rd-ok.ru/age-of-empires-download-windows-10-age-of-empires/
    https://rd-ok.ru/download-windows-10-pro-64-bit-latest-version/

    live mail download for windows 7 free [/url] wireless mouse driver download windows 10 [/url] game free download for pc [/url] earth download free 2016 for windows 10 free [/url] viber for windows 10 64 bit [/url] reader windows 10 free download free [/url] free download windows 10 free [/url] wheeler truck games free download for windows 7 free [/url] player download for pc windows 7 32 bit [/url] studio download for windows 10 [/url]
    Annasysvem

Leave a comment

x